# diffs for urn requirements doc

Karen R. Sollins (sollins@lcs.mit.edu)
Sat, 6 Aug 94 22:45:29 -0400

- Messages sorted by: [ date ][ thread ][ subject ][ author ]
- Next message: Larry Masinter: "Re: URL Comments"
- Previous message: Mitra: "Latest URL draft - diffs please"

    Date: Sat, 6 Aug 94 22:45:29 -0400

    Message-Id: <9408070245.AA20555@zippy.lcs.mit.edu>

    From: "Karen R. Sollins" <sollins@lcs.mit.edu>

    To: uri@bunyip.com

    Subject: diffs for urn requirements doc

3,5c3,5
< draft-sollins-urn-01.txt L. Masinter
< Expires January 5, 1995 Xerox Corporation
< June 30, 1994

    ---
    > draft-ietf-uri-urn-req-00.txt				    L. Masinter
    > Replaces draft-sollins-urn-01.txt		      Xerox Corporation
    > Expires February 9, 1995				 August 9, 1994
    60c60
    < INTERNET-DRAFT	Requirements for Uniform Resource Names	    June 30,1994

    ---
    > INTERNET-DRAFT	Requirements for Uniform Resource Names	   August 9,1994
    84,85c84,85
    <       persistent identifier used both for recognition and for
    <       access to characteristics of or access to the resource.

    ---
    >       persistent identifier used both for recognition and for access
    >       to characteristics of the resource or access to the resource.
    118c118
    < INTERNET-DRAFT	Requirements for Uniform Resource Names	   June 30, 1994

    ---
    > INTERNET-DRAFT	Requirements for Uniform Resource Names	  August 9, 1994
    175c175
    < INTERNET-DRAFT	Requirements for Uniform Resource Names    June 30, 1994

    ---
    > INTERNET-DRAFT	Requirements for Uniform Resource Names   August 9, 1994
    176a177
    >
    180,181c181,184
    <    requirements. Some design decisions are a direct result of these
    <    requirements:

    ---
    >    requirements.  We draw a set of conclusions, listed below, from
    >    those requirements; a specification that satisfies the requirments
    >    without meetings these conclusions is deemed acceptable, although
    >    unlikely to occur.
    187c190
    <      guarantee uniqueness.  The name of the naming authorities

    ---
    >      guarantee uniqueness.  The names of the naming authorities
    211a215,216
    > 5. Other considerations
    >
    224,227c229,231
    <    make that distinction.  Furthermore, it may be that the algorithms
    <    used by neither of these two sources of URNs for a book has a basis by
    <    which to compare two spreadsheets.  Thus, although this document
    <    requires that any particular naming authority use one algorithm for

    ---
    >    make that distinction.  Furthermore, no one algorithm for testing
    >    for equality is likely to applicable to all sorts of information.
    >    For example, an algorithm based on testing the equality of two
    232c236
    < INTERNET-DRAFT	Requirements for Uniform Resource Names	   June 30, 1994

    ---
    > INTERNET-DRAFT	Requirements for Uniform Resource Names	  August 9, 1994
    235,237c239,244
    <    determining whether two resources it is comparing are the same or
    <    different, each naming authority can use a different such algorithm
    <    and a naming authority may restrict the set of resources it chooses to

    ---
    >    books is unlikely to be useful when testing the equality of two
    >    spreadsheets.  Thus, although this document requires that any
    >    particular naming authority use one algorithm for determining
    >    whether two resources it is comparing are the same or different,
    >    each naming authority can use a different such algorithm and a
    >    naming authority may restrict the set of resources it chooses to
    284a292,294
    >
    >
    >
    287c297
    < INTERNET-DRAFT	Requirements for Uniform Resource Names	   June 30, 1994

    ---
    > INTERNET-DRAFT	Requirements for Uniform Resource Names	  August 9, 1994
    288a299
    >
    302,308c313,319
    <    Larry Masinter   			Karen Sollins
    <    Xerox Palo Alto Research Center	MIT Laboratory for Computer Science
    <    3333 Coyote Hill Road		545 Technology Square
    <    Palo Alto, CA 94304			Cambridge, MA 02139
    <    masinter@parc.xerox.com		sollins@lcs.mit.edu
    <    Voice: (415) 812-4365		Voice: (617) 253-6006
    <    Fax:   (415) 812-4333		Tel:   (617) 253-2673

    ---
    >    Larry Masinter   		     Karen Sollins
    >    Xerox Palo Alto Research Center   MIT Laboratory for Computer Science
    >    3333 Coyote Hill Road	     545 Technology Square
    >    Palo Alto, CA 94304		     Cambridge, MA 02139
    >    masinter@parc.xerox.com	     sollins@lcs.mit.edu
    >    Voice: (415) 812-4365	     Voice: (617) 253-6006
    >    Fax:   (415) 812-4333	     Tel:   (617) 253-2673
    318d328
    < Sollins & Masinter						[Page 6]
    322a333,356
    >
    >
    >
    >
    >
    >
    >
    >
    >
    >
    >
    >
    >
    >
    >
    >
    >
    >
    >
    >
    >
    >
    >
    > Sollins & Masinter						[Page 6]

     Next message: Larry Masinter: "Re: URL Comments"
     Previous message: Mitra: "Latest URL draft - diffs please"