# Re: Persistent Documents and Locations

Karen R. Sollins (sollins@lcs.mit.edu)
Mon, 21 Aug 1995 19:21:20 -0400

- Messages sorted by: [ date ][ thread ][ subject ][ author ]
- Next message: Terry Allen: "Re: Persistent Documents and Locations"
- Previous message: Karen R. Sollins: "Re: Persistent Documents and Locations"
- In reply to: lazear@dockside.mitre.org: "Re: Persistent Documents and Locations"
- Next in thread: Brian Behlendorf: "Re: Persistent Documents and Locations"
- Reply: Brian Behlendorf: "Re: Persistent Documents and Locations"

    Date: Mon, 21 Aug 1995 19:21:20 -0400

    Message-Id: <199508212321.TAA10110@lysithea.lcs.mit.edu>

    From: "Karen R. Sollins" <sollins@lcs.mit.edu>

    To: lazear@dockside.mitre.org

    In-Reply-To: <9508211941.AA21609@dockside.mitre.org> (lazear@dockside.mitre.org)

    Subject: Re: Persistent Documents and Locations

From: lazear@dockside.mitre.org
Cc: uri@bunyip.com, lazear@dockside.mitre.org
Date: Mon, 21 Aug 95 15:41:41 -0400

...

One problem: who validates URNs, since they are the
longest-lived element in the UR* universe? Like DNS,
one can find out that a URN is no longer valid. The issue
then is to find out a source from which one can get the new
form of the URN or an alternate URN or confirmation that the
URN doesn't exist at all anymore. This is usually an offline
task (like calling a friend to learn what the real domain
name is).

Walt

Well, no, I think you've misunderstood RFC 1737. The intention for
URNs is that they are valid in perpetuity. If the object is still
around, in 10 yrs, then the URN for it is still "valid". I can't go
into a long diatribe now, but there is a great deal behind the choice
of making URNs global and long-lived. But, suffice it to say that
URNs don't expire or become invalid. The resources they name may be
deleted, but the URN should never be re-used or reassigned. For each
URN the assigment of it happens no more than once, ever.

Karen

- Next message: Terry Allen: "Re: Persistent Documents and Locations"
- Previous message: Karen R. Sollins: "Re: Persistent Documents and Locations"
- In reply to: lazear@dockside.mitre.org: "Re: Persistent Documents and Locations"
- Next in thread: Brian Behlendorf: "Re: Persistent Documents and Locations"
- Reply: Brian Behlendorf: "Re: Persistent Documents and Locations"